Im trying to come back with the idea of a fun thread from a long time ago. This time share your thoughts about your club and one other club's players. Lets keep this simple. One underrated player and one overrated player for each club.

Il start with mine:

United:

Underrated - Phil Jones
Overrated - Adnan Januzaj

Barcelona:

Underrated - Montoya
Overrated - Dani Alves

^ Is Draxler actually overrated? I don't watch much German football so I don't know

I'm not sure if some of you know what under/overrated means. Matic in underrated ? It's pretty common knowledge among epl fans that he is a beast. Same can be said with azpi, everyone knows he's a great fullback. In the same way, Ramirez is not overrated, everyone knows he's decent, but not very good. Just like Busquets is not underrated, this was true in 2010, when barça were on the brink of becoming one of the best teams in history. But now it's accepted by everyone that he's been one of the best DM in europe over the last 4 years. Same with modric, he was one of the best CMs if not the best in the world last season. He's not underrated.

Arsenal :

underrated : Szczesny, Gibbs (should be starting for england)
overrated : Ospina

@Rama
good player but he doesn't have 40mil worth in qualities imo.

edit: and of course after i wrote that tonight he'll score an hattrick -_-

@KingHenry: I agree that I don't see Matic as underrated but I rarely see people call Azpi one of the best fullbacks in Europe, which he really is.

EVERTON:

OVERRATED - LUKAKU
UNDERRATED - NAISMITH

@Rama How is Ramos overrated?

The most underrated player in the world, well maybe not but he's close. I've said it many times : Matteo Darmian

^Darmian is good,check Kramaric from Croatia...

I couldn't find better video,but he is beast in Croatian league.

Finally a club is with me.... but sadly its United.

Yes thats right, United have finally seen Darmian's talent and are planning a bid in January.

Inter
Underrated - Handanović
overrated - Guarin

Spurs
Underrated - Eriksen
Overrated - Lamela

Wolfie, how do you come by Lamela being overrated?

Liverpool:
Overrated: Balotelli (even worse than Carroll imo, Carroll at least got a good work rate)
Underrated: Joe Allen (seriously, his passing and movement is insane in many crucial occasions)

Manchester City
Overrated: Vincent Kompany
Underrated: Pablo Zabaleta

P Scott. You are not a true Manchester City fan. If you were, you of all persons would know that Vincent Kompany is not overrated

Under - Wickham
Over Shea

Under - AC Milans Honda.

Over - Ozil, but for gods sake put him in a position where he does his most damage.

liverpool
overrated mario
underrated borini