Forum
{{ post.commentCount }}

Didn't find anything.

{{ searchResult.errors[0] }}



Comparison polls: Ultimate Edition
Emobot7 8 years ago Edited
543 11478

So, I realized that making comparison poll was pretty succeful and fun to make, so I thought, why do I limit myself to doing only one comparison a thread and why not ask other to join in the fun. So, what I'm proprosing here is to make a thread where we compare similar player with only polls and with the least chit-chat possible. If we wanna discuss a comparison, we make a new thread for it instead. People are welcome to post poll asking other user who they think is the best between:

  1. Two player playing in similar position (or area at the very least) and for the same team.
  2. Two player from the same contry and playing in similar position or area of the field.
  3. Two player player from the same league who play in similar position or area of the field.
  4. Two player from different league but with very similar play-style and position.
  5. Two player who play at the same position or area and both played for a specific team at one point.

So remember, only post a brief explanation as to why you are comparing those player (ex: both are winger at Chelsea, both play CB for Germany) and then the poll. Limit discution to a minimum and make other thread if you really want to discuss a comparison and try to compare player wich might be comparable (don't compare young player like Munir to big star like Neymar for exemple) and most of all, have fun! Let's get those poll started! ;D

0
  • History
Showing previous versions of this text.

So, I realized that making comparison poll was pretty succeful and fun to make, so I thought, why do I limit myself to doing only one comparison a thread and why not ask other to join in the fun. So, what I'm proprosing here is to make a thread where we compare similar player with only polls and with the least chit-chat possible. If we wanna discuss a comparison, we make a new thread for it instead. People are welcome to post poll asking other user who they think is the best between:

  1. Two player playing in similar position (or area at the very least and for the same team.
  2. Two player from the same contry and playing in similar position or area of the field.
  3. Two player player from the same league who play in similar position or area of the field.
  4. Two player from different league but with very similar play-style and position.
  5. Two player who play at the same position or area and both played for a specific team at one point.

So remember, only post a brief explanation as to why you are comparing those player (ex: both are winger at Chelsea, both play CB for Germany) and then the poll. Limit discution to a minimum and make other thread if you really want to discuss a comparison and try to compare player wich might be comparable (don't compare young player like Munir to big star like Neymar for exemple) and more of all, have fun! Let's get those poll started! ;D

So, I realized that making comparison poll was pretty succeful and fun to make, so I thought, why do I limit myself to doing only one comparison a thread and why not ask other to join in the fun. So, what I'm proprosing here is to make a thread where we compare similar player with only polls and with the least chit-chat possible. If we wanna discuss a comparison, we make a new thread for it instead. People are welcome to post poll asking other user who they think is the best between:

  1. Two player playing in similar position (or area at the very least) and for the same team.
  2. Two player from the same contry and playing in similar position or area of the field.
  3. Two player player from the same league who play in similar position or area of the field.
  4. Two player from different league but with very similar play-style and position.
  5. Two player who play at the same position or area and both played for a specific team at one point.

So remember, only post a brief explanation as to why you are comparing those player (ex: both are winger at Chelsea, both play CB for Germany) and then the poll. Limit discution to a minimum and make other thread if you really want to discuss a comparison and try to compare player wich might be comparable (don't compare young player like Munir to big star like Neymar for exemple) and more of all, have fun! Let's get those poll started! ;D

Comments
Emobot7 8 years ago Edited
543 11478
0
  • History
Showing previous versions of this text.
SunFlash 8 years ago
USA 19 3260

Why would Robben not be better than Ribery? Yeah, 2013 Ribery was fantastic, but that's not his constant form. Agree with you on Alonso, but NOT on Inestia. Modric is good, but Inestia was the cog in (what is my opinion) the best side ever, Pep's Barca.

0
Eden17Hazard17 8 years ago
Chelsea FC 157 4232

Can we please try and use full names, because my OCD is kicking in :P

0
JuanMata10 8 years ago
Chelsea, Austria 17 1696

Are we talking about who's better right now or who's been better throughout the last couple of years? Partly agree with @SunFlash and partly with @Dynastian.

If we're talking about right now it would look like this for me:
Modric > Iniesta
Robben > Ribery

If we're talking about the whole career:
Iniesta > Modric
Robben > Ribery again

0
Dynastian98 8 years ago
Real Madrid 483 7140

Maybe you're right about the Robben-Ribery debate, but @Sunflash I was speaking of Modric vs. Iniesta at this very moment, not Modric vs. Iniesta throughout their entire careers.

0