This is how I would rank them. Will add Market value from transfermarkt and transfer cost too (in pounds).
- Pogba MV:59,5 TC:89,25
- Gundogan MV:35,5 TC:23
- Kante MV:25,5 TC:30,5
- Xhaka MV:30 TC:38,25
- Wanyama MV:12,75 TC:12,25
- Wijnaldum MV:18,70 TC: 23,25
I feel they are all pretty different players even though their positions are similar.. Wijnaldum is more offensive minded, attacking midfieldish?.. and not really a CM?
I feel that Kante is the best DM, as he's best played deep. I mean he's defenitively the best tackler of the 6 players, and he's great at intercepting and clearing balls.. Probably the best out of these players to played deep in a pretty stuck role..
Wanyama is also a proper DM, but I feel that he isn't as good as Kante. far from actually. I also feel that he might have reached his full potential at this point.. at the other hand he was fairly cheep and still a good signing.
Gundogan meanwhile is probably the best player over all, meaning that he's got both attributes suitable for defense and offense. Great at passing and creating opportunities for other players.. And they got him for a bargain price too..
Pogba is naturally the clear choice for most people, but I've never really understood he's way of playing.. He undoubtedly provided the most chances, key passes and assists etc when he played for Juventus in comparison to the other players. and he scored every now and then too.. Something that Kante for example wouldn't do very often as he's a proper DM. Pogba is also tall and athletic so a great head player which is a nice feature.. But, he's also prone to wasting chances, and sometimes he has to try a lot of times before he nailes it. Overall, I'd pick Pogba in before all other players, but he's not worth that amount of money at all.. I'd have him first as a CM with a pretty free role to give him the opportunity to create..
Xhaka seems to be alright, but am not as convinced of him as others seem to be.. As the second most pricey player of them 6, I feel that he might be a bit overpriced.. Happen to know that he's wages are relatively low though which probably makes up for that. Have to wait and see with him I guess.
Overall, I think at least 1 will fail, and not live up to their expectations. Xhaka, Wijnaldum or Wanyama?
I believe that Pogba, Gundogan and Kante will be great signings though. Although Pogba is no way close worth that amount of money.. but if we ignore that fact.. I believe he'll be great at United.
xhaka vs pogba vs kante vs wanyama vs wijnaldum vs gundogan
thats new central midfielder signings from the top 6 teams in england.......how would you rank them???.....they are all relatively young too aged between 23-25.
xhaka vs pogba vs kante vs wanyama vs wijnaldum vs gundogan
xhaka vs pogba vs kante vs wanyama vs wijnaldum vs gundogan
thats new central midfielder signings from the top 6 teams in england.......how would you rank them???