Ok so this thread might sound irrelevant, but I really want to know your opinion on this matter. My brother ( a die hard Barcelona fan) thinks that Pique is still considered a top 5 CB. What do you think about that? Don't forget to list your 5.

My list:
1- Sergio Ramos/Thiago Silva
2-Matts Hummles
3-Vincent Kompany
4-Benatia
5-Chiellini

Hardly on the top 15 any more.

1. Silva
2. Boateng
3. Ramos
4. Hummels
5. Benatia

Pique is out of my top 30, at least!
My top 5 defenders
Hummels
Thiago Silva
Ramos
Terry
Benatia

Thiago Silva, Sergio Ramos, Vincent Kompany, Matts Hummels, don't know who to pick 5th but honorable mentions for: Benatia, Godin, Koscielny, Cahill, Vertonghen
I just don't see Pique near the top 5, Barcelona should try to play Vermaelen instead.

@Tuanis srry bro, I meant CB so I just edited it :p

Is Piqué still considered as a Footballer ? He is more peforming on twitter or woth his wife than in a Football pitch.
Piqué should leave, i cant stand him anymore and he seems ignorant about his performences he thinks highly of himself, for me its Barça's Mario.

True, I find it very sad that he fell off just like that. Give Bartra a go dammit!

I can't make a list but I can easily say Pique won't make it to at least Top20.

Pique's out of my 25 at least because of his social life, but I do think he'll regain some form if he moves to a good club and gains confidence.

In terms of just defending, I say Benatia is the best in the world, but defenders have to have more than that so Ramos, Lahm and even Ivanovic are good picks.

My Top 20 (in no specific order)

Terry
Howedes
Boateng
Benatia
Ramos
Silva
Martinez
Kompany
Mascherano
Cahill
Godin
Miranda
Hummels
Chiellini
Vertonghen
Bazargli
Sokratis
Ivanovic (a CB imo)
Varane
Laporte

Going to a team where there is less pressure would only make it worse, if he cant give his 100 per cent at Barcelona, do you think he will even try in PL ?
He used to be world class, he complained about Cesc departure but for me he was lucky not being sold himself, nobody wanted him while Cesc and Alexis provided good amounts of cash.
He is absolutely one of the people to blame at Barça, flopped when we needed him most when he didnt have any competition.
Now that Mathieu and Vermaelen are bought i wish he never see a starting line up even if he becomes a monster, some things arent forgetable.
Dont mind if he got bashed, he surely deserves it and Enrique even more for starting this s**ker again. I though Enrique had balls when he decided to rebuild midlefield with fresh players and bench Piqué, but when I saw Piqué-Mascerano in the back + completely off form Busquets( back from injury)-Xavi (off form) -Iniesta ( injured during the game) i was like why are you even coaching if you cant change anything ?

His post game conference was a midtable team coach reaction, you can take your staff and go back to Celta Vigo if you think this kind of reactions are welcome at Barça. He still has 3 months to deliver and find solutions, Messi wont hide our weaknesses in CL.
Messi deserves a better team, and definitely a better coach, Disappointed Enrique, we just couldnt start the game better and still lost, keep your useless post game reactions for your kids, you are in charge of Barça not Chivas.

Well, now i feel better :).

1. Silva
2. Ramos
3. Hummels
4. Godin
5. Benatia/Cahill

1. Ramos
2. Hummels
3. Silva
4. Pepe
5. Godín

1- Silva
2- Ramos
3- Godin
4- Kompany
5- Benatia

1:Kompany
2: Silva
3: Cahill
4:Boateng
5:Varane

Pique is in my top 30, but not top 25... so you fellas can get a picture... in his good days he can be in top 10 or even 5, but he consistently makes silly mistakes... it's almost hard to believe that he is not dropped for the big games

1.Thiago Silva
2.Hummels
3.Sergio Ramos
4.Kompany
5.Pepe/Miranda/Godin (All of them are fantastic)

Pique isn't in my top 20 for sure...Maybe in his best days,but not now.

1. Silva
2. Kompany
3. Hummels
4. Godin
5. Cahill

1. Thiago Silva
2. Pepe
3. Hummels
4. Kompany
5. Boateng

Pique is a wankstain now

thiago silva
hummels
filipe luis
kompany
marcos rojo